Is cat toilet training a good idea?

Training your cat to use the toilet might seem like a good idea, but is it really the best choice for you and your feline friend? In this guide, we’ll explore the pros and cons of cat toilet training, alternatives that work, and why sticking to litter boxes might be the better option for both you and your cat...

Key points:

• Cat toilet training can eliminate litter box chores but comes with risks and drawbacks.
• Toilet training cats can cause stress and make it hard to monitor their health.
• Alternatives like automatic litter boxes provide a more practical solution.

Should you toilet train your cat?

Toilet training your cat comes with several downsides that could impact your feline friend's well-being. Cats are instinctively programmed to dig, scratch, and bury their waste. Training your cat to use the toilet interrupts these natural behaviors and may create unnecessary stress for your kitty companion. While some cats can adapt to toilet training, the process is not without its challenges - and drawbacks.

Pros of cat toilet training

There are a few perceived benefits that make toilet training your cat attractive to some pet parents, such as:

1. Avoiding litter box cleaning

With your cat using the toilet, you can say goodbye to the daily task of scooping and cleaning a litter tray. For busy pet parents, this can save valuable time and make day-to-day life a little easier. 

2. It can help reduce the smell in your home

A toilet-trained cat eliminates the issues of stray litter and lingering odors. Without a litter box, your home may smell fresher, especially in small spaces. This potential perk is one of the main reasons some pet parents consider cat litter box toilet training. 

3. It reduces the space a litter tray takes up

Litter trays can take up valuable floor space, which isn’t ideal in smaller apartments or homes! Using a cat potty training seat instead frees up that area.

Cons of cat toilet training

Toilet training a cat could be a clever solution - bye-bye to litter boxes, right? But before you commit to a cat toilet bowl trainer, let’s look at the reasons why this approach might not be ideal for either you or your furry beloved...

1. You could miss the symptoms of a medical problem

Your cat’s waste can reveal a lot about their health. Changes like diarrhea, blood, or irregularities in the litter box often signal potential health issues. If your cat is using a toilet, you’re far less likely to notice these warning signs in time to take action.

2. Your cat might fall into the toilet

Toilets aren’t designed for cats - a slip or fall into the water can be frightening, and even cause injury. A single bad experience might leave your cat scared of using the toilet, creating accidents and stress for both of you.

3. It could stress your cat out

Cats thrive on routines and natural instincts, like scratching, digging, and covering their waste. These are all ingrained habits that help cats feel secure, and toilet training removes these behaviors, which can result in unnecessary anxiety or behavioral problems, such as refusing to go to the bathroom altogether.

4. They have to assume an uncomfortable position

Balancing on a slippery toilet seat isn’t natural for cats! This awkward posture can lead to accidents and discourage them from using the toilet, especially if they feel unstable or unsafe.

5. A toilet-trained cat can't travel

A toilet-trained cat might struggle to adapt when faced with a litter box if they need to travel - this can result in accidents and added stress for your pet in unfamiliar surroundings.

6. The toilet must always be accessible

Unlike a litter box, which can be placed anywhere, a toilet-trained cat has only one option. If the bathroom is occupied or inaccessible, your cat could end up with no place to go, leading to messy accidents.

6. It could cause other issues around your home

For some cats, the toilet may become less of a tool and more of a toy. They might flush the toilet out of curiosity or treat the water bowl as an extra play spot, leading to wasted water or hygiene concerns.

Toilet training your cat might appear a good idea, but the stress it causes, the risks involved, and the disruption to their natural instincts make it clear that sticking with a litter box is the kinder, safer choice!

Alternatives to cat toilet training

Rather than teaching your cat to use the toilet, consider these alternatives that cater to your cat’s instincts and ensure their comfort.

Litter box training

Training your cat to consistently use a litter box is the simplest and most effective option. Choose a location that’s quiet and easy for your cat to access, and keep the box clean to encourage use. Explore litter options that suit your cat’s preferences, such as unscented or clumping varieties.

Related article: How to set up your cat's litter box

Automatic litter boxes

For those who want to minimize scooping, automatic litter boxes can help. These high-tech solutions clean themselves after each use, keeping the area tidy and reducing odors. Popular models include features like odor control and multi-cat compatibility, making them a convenient option for busy households.

Access to nature’s toilet

If you have an outdoor space, allowing your cat access to a secure garden or yard lets them use natural surfaces like soil or sand, which aligns with their instincts. This option provides mental stimulation and mimics their wild behaviors, but it does have its drawbacks. For one thing, you may not be able to keep a close eye on your kitty's bathroom habits and monitor for potential changes.

Keep your cat happy and stress-free with the right care options. Learn how TrustedHousesitters connects you with pet-loving sitters who prioritize your cat’s comfort below.